Violence against elderly pro-life advocates sparks outrage as the assailant faces sentencing.
Story Overview
- Patrick Brice convicted of assaulting elderly pro-life protesters.
- Video of the attack has intensified public outcry.
- Brice acquitted of first-degree assault; sentencing for lesser charges pending.
- Case highlights ongoing tensions over abortion rights and protester safety.
Violent Attack on Pro-Life Advocates
On May 26, 2023, Patrick Brice attacked two elderly pro-life advocates, Mark Crosby and Richard Schaefer, outside a Planned Parenthood clinic in Baltimore. The incident, captured on surveillance video, showed Brice violently assaulting the men, leading to severe injuries for Crosby. The video circulated widely, drawing attention to the brutality of the attack and sparking national outrage among pro-life advocates and their supporters. Brice was convicted of second-degree assault and reckless endangerment in February 2025.
The attack has become a focal point in the ongoing debates over the safety of pro-life protesters. The victims, both elderly, were known for their regular presence outside the clinic, engaging in sidewalk advocacy. This type of protest activity has been a long-standing and contentious issue in the United States. The assault has amplified concerns regarding the vulnerability of pro-life demonstrators and the broader implications for free speech rights.
Legal Proceedings and Acquittal
Following the attack, Brice was arrested in June 2023 but released without bail. His trial began in February 2025, where he was convicted on lesser charges. However, the jury could not reach a verdict on the first-degree assault charge, leading to a retrial. On June 25, 2025, Judge Yvette M. Bryant acquitted Brice of first-degree assault, citing ambiguity in the video evidence. This decision has been met with criticism from pro-life groups, who argue that the acquittal undermines the seriousness of the attack.
Mark Crosby expressed dissatisfaction with the legal process, alleging a bias against pro-life advocates. The State’s Attorney’s Office had initially announced plans to retry Brice on the first-degree charge, reflecting the high stakes and contentious nature of the case. The acquittal, however, has shifted focus to the upcoming sentencing for the remaining convictions scheduled for August 7, 2025.
Impact on Abortion Debate and Protest Safety
The case has reignited tensions between pro-life and pro-choice groups, with both sides using the incident to highlight their respective concerns. The pro-life community views the attack as evidence of systemic bias and vulnerability, while pro-choice advocates stress the importance of ensuring safety and peaceful protest. The Baltimore community faces renewed debate over protest rights and public safety, with potential implications for national policy on protester safety and clinic security.
Amidst increasing polarization, the case underscores the delicate balance between free speech and public safety. Legal analysts point to the challenges of securing convictions for violent acts at politically charged demonstrations, emphasizing the need for clearer guidelines and law enforcement response. As the August sentencing approaches, advocacy groups remain vigilant, preparing to respond to the court’s decision and its broader implications for protester rights and safety.
