Cops Aimed SPY Cameras at Their Own Officer

Security camera overlaid on hands typing at a laptop
Photo: ImageFlow / Shutterstock

The fight over San Diego’s Flock cameras was never really a fight about whether automated license-plate readers catch criminals — they do, reliably and often. It was a fight about what happens when the same infrastructure built to catch criminals gets pointed, quietly and without a warrant, at an ordinary citizen police wanted to watch for reasons that had nothing to do with public safety.

Key Points

  • San Diego’s City Council voted unanimously on November 16 to rescind authorization for roughly 500 Flock Safety license-plate-reader cameras and end the city’s related smart-streetlight contract.
  • Police credited the network with contributing to 941 cases, 706 arrests, and the recovery of 689 stolen vehicles since 2023 — a record that initially won bipartisan council support.
  • The reversal followed disclosures that SDPD internal-affairs investigators used the system to track an officer and a domestic-violence victim suspected of a relationship with him.
  • National academic research on ALPR technology shows it reliably increases arrests and recoveries but has not been shown to reduce overall crime rates — a gap that fueled skepticism about the program’s net benefit.
  • San Diego joins a growing list of cities, including Santa Ana and Beacon, New York, reconsidering or ending Flock contracts amid similar misuse allegations.

How Automated License-Plate Readers Actually Work

Flock Safety’s cameras are fixed, solar-powered units that photograph every license plate passing within range, timestamp and geotag the image, and upload it to a searchable cloud database shared across participating agencies. San Diego’s roughly 500 units captured millions of plate images monthly, retaining the data for about a month before automatic deletion, with SDPD officers able to query the system by plate number, partial plate, or vehicle description. Unlike a manual patrol check, which requires an officer to physically observe and run a plate, ALPR networks scan continuously and indiscriminately, which is precisely what makes them effective investigative tools — and precisely what worries privacy advocates.

That indiscriminate scanning is the mechanism behind both halves of the controversy. The same database that let detectives recover 689 stolen vehicles and build cases tied to kidnappings and firearm recoveries also let internal-affairs investigators pull the location history of an officer under investigation and, reportedly, a domestic-violence victim suspected of having a relationship with him — without the victim being the subject of any criminal case herself. A tool with no narrow use case, by design, has no narrow misuse case either.

From Public-Safety Asset to Political Liability

San Diego installed the cameras in 2023 with relatively little public friction, and for two years the program’s defenders had a straightforward numbers argument: police said the network had helped solve 941 cases and make 706 arrests, figures that made the technology politically durable even as privacy groups raised abstract concerns about mass data collection. That calculus changed in November 2026, when reporting surfaced that SDPD’s internal-affairs unit had used the system in August 2025 to surveil an officer under misconduct investigation and, separately, a domestic-violence victim believed to have been involved with him — a use case that had nothing to do with stolen cars or kidnappings and everything to do with department-internal matters.

The disclosure reframed the debate overnight. Ted Womack Jr., vice chair of the city’s Privacy Advisory Board — the very body charged with overseeing surveillance technology — called the episode troubling, lending institutional weight to what had previously been dismissed as advocacy-group alarmism. Councilmember Raul Campillo, who had supported the program, publicly withdrew his backing and demanded an immediate suspension and audit, arguing that until safeguards against misuse were demonstrated, continued operation could not be justified. Several colleagues who had not fully supported the program before found Campillo’s reversal, following the same disclosure, enough to tip a unanimous vote.

What the Vote Actually Did

On November 16, the council voted unanimously to rescind SDPD’s authorization to use Flock technology and to terminate the city’s separate $2 million annual contract with Ubicquia, the vendor behind roughly 500 “smart streetlight” cameras woven through the same surveillance debate. The cameras were ordered deactivated within roughly 24 hours, with collected data to be purged rather than retained. Notably, the hardware itself was not torn down — the physical units remain mounted on poles across the city, authorization simply withdrawn, meaning a future council could, in principle, reactivate the network without reinstalling anything.

Public comment leading into the vote ran “nearly unanimously” against continuing the program, according to coverage of the hearing, with residents citing both the internal-affairs disclosure and broader unease about government overreach. That near-unanimity among speakers, paired with a unanimous council vote, is a rare alignment in municipal surveillance disputes, which more typically split along predictable lines between crime-conscious constituencies and civil-liberties constituencies. Here, the misuse allegation collapsed that divide — people who otherwise differed sharply on policing policy agreed that a tool built to find stolen cars should not have been turned on a domestic-violence victim.

Where the Research Actually Lands

Strip away the specific San Diego scandal and the underlying technology debate is older and more settled than the headlines suggest. Multiple independent evaluations — including a multi-site study from the Policing Institute — have found that ALPR deployment reliably increases plate scans, stolen-vehicle alerts, and arrests compared with manual patrol checks. But the same body of research has consistently failed to find that ALPR deployment reduces overall auto theft or crime rates once the technology is in place; a widely cited hot-spot policing study found no general or offense-specific deterrent effect from LPR patrols. Federal evaluators reached a similar conclusion: the systems scan more plates and generate more hits, but the underlying incidence of auto theft did not decline after deployment.

That distinction — more leads versus less crime — is the real fault line beneath San Diego’s vote, and it is why “the cameras helped solve 941 cases” and “the cameras should be shut down” are not actually contradictory claims. A tool can be operationally useful in individual investigations while still failing to demonstrate the kind of population-level public-safety benefit that would justify blanket, suspicionless data collection on every driver who passes a given intersection. San Diego’s internal-affairs episode simply made that abstract cost-benefit question concrete and personal, which is usually what it takes to move a city council from unanimous support to a unanimous reversal.

The Wider Pattern Now Unfolding

San Diego is not an isolated case. Within roughly 48 hours of its vote, Santa Ana’s council voted 6-0 to end its own Flock arrangement, and Beacon, New York, terminated its contract as well, suggesting the misuse disclosure functioned less as a local scandal than as a catalyst that crystallized doubts several cities were already nursing about vendor contracts, data retention, and oversight gaps. Flock Safety itself has maintained, through local reporting, that the disputed uses were permitted under existing department policy — a defense that, if accurate, points to an even more unsettling conclusion than deliberate abuse: that the written rules governing these systems were simply not written tightly enough to prevent exactly this outcome. Cities weighing new or renewed ALPR contracts now face a template neither side disputes — the technology works as advertised; the governance around it, in this instance, did not.

Sources:

youtube.com, nbcsandiego.com, sandiegouniontribune.com, fox5sandiego.com, cbs8.com, yahoo.com, hsaj.org, scholarship.law.tamu.edu